A universal question in any sport, at any level, is “What is my coach looking for in filling his roster?” And, “What can I do to make the team?”
There is no exact science to a coach’s decision for his or her roster. The reality is, there are several variables out of a player’s control that could dictate the eventual roster plan. Such examples include positional depth, coach’s style of play, and number of players on the roster.
Some of the questions a coach will ask themselves within their evaluation of each player will likely be: Can they help us be a better team? Are they currently improving? Are they coachable? Do they have a good attitude? Can they play defense? Can they complete multiple skills of the game?
That said, let’s speak to the positive ways that a player can persuade the coach in his or her favor.
These include being calm on the court, being in the right place on both sides of the ball, being a good teammate and quality decision-maker, being fundamentally sound and maintaining a strong work ethic through adversity. Coaches will also look for the ability to make shots, good conditioning and high-character, low-maintenance players.
I believe performing or showing these traits within a tryout will put you on a short list when decision time comes for the coaching staff.
There are also some things to avoid doing during a tryout that could hurt your chances of making a team, including, having an over-emotional reaction to a mistake of yours or a teammate, judging a teammate, arriving late, not making eye-contact, and not fully listening or implementing instruction.
Regardless of the outcome of a tryout, remember that it is only a review of one point in time in a player’s career. Making a team is never a finality; it is the beginning of a chapter with a new team that will demand your best moving forward.
Do not make a big deal about personal achievement. It is better to stay humble and consistent. If you were not to make a team, use it as a motivation to improve, and learn from staff what areas of development are needed.
As they say, the richest soil is in a valley, and the best learning doesn’t come from winning. Not making a roster in high school did not stop Michael Jordan!
Personally, I have failed many times but I tried not to let it define me. A good quote to work off is, “Your success may be delayed, but you are not defeated.”
I wish everyone good luck with their tryouts, whether it be CYO, AAU, high school, college or pro. The joy is in the journey, not the reward.
Charles Marquardt, Sr., is the Men’s Basketball head coach at Mercy University and all-time winningest coach at Molloy University. Charles Marquardt, Jr. is a professional basketball player who led the Canadian Basketball Super League in scoring and was named Most Valuable Player.






